|
karbalagurl (November 30, 1999 at 12:00 am)
BEAUTIFUL! VERY BEAUTIFUL!
ShiaAfghan (November 30, 1999 at 12:00 am)
I dare you to use your own logic when you are praying. I hope Allah accepts your prayers.
Secondly, if you had actually read my arguments, you would have seen that I am addressing Iranians/Pakis/Afghans living in the West. None of these groups have the equivalent "dh" and I don't expect natives of these countries to change their dialect. However, many of us are born and raised in America. If I can say "dh", then so can you.
I dare you to say "ZZZaleen" in Surah Fatiha when you are praying.
malekeh (November 30, 1999 at 12:00 am)
Are you getting mad at how people PRONOUNCE a certain name in History?
WHAT THE H*LL ?!
THINK A LITTLE, PLEASE.
THE WAY THE PRONOUNCE THE NAME (because of the way the farsi alphabet is) DOESNT TAKE AWAY ANYTHING FROM THE WHOLE MESSAGE,
WHY ARE YOU SITTING THERE PICKING AT THE FACT OF THE SLIGHT VARIATION IN THE PRONOUNCIATION .. RATHER THAN TO TAKE IN THE MESSAGE ????!
in FARSI there is no alphabetiacal letter for the arabic sound "DH" Iranis instead say "Z"
OGHAD (November 30, 1999 at 12:00 am)
yeh u know wat.. stag firallah ur right.. im sorry i just loose my patience with stupid comments.. my point is there r more important issues we as muslims shud be adressin right now stop being so fanatical plz!
ShiaAfghan (November 30, 1999 at 12:00 am)
Racist comments and name-calling? I'm flattered.
OGHAD, how can you glorify Allah in the same comment in which you perpetuate asabiyyah and call others name?
It's a sad time for Muslims when we resort to mud-slinging and childish name-calling rather than using rational arguments.
And you have the audacity to call ME the child?
OGHAD (November 30, 1999 at 12:00 am)
dude would you listen to yourself???? did u not just hear what mr shirazi is singing about... bloody typical afghan as if its important u fucken idiot!!!! subhan allah so many spastics out there!!! and gypsy if a two year old wants to argue wid u do u argue back?? leave the idiot alone
ShiaAfghan (November 30, 1999 at 12:00 am)
"Farsi isNT the original Parsi language anymore, its a combination of Parsi & THE INFLUENCE of other languages - "
You're right. I believe the modern equivalent of Old Persian is Dari, which is spoken in Afghanistan today.
ShiaAfghan (November 30, 1999 at 12:00 am)
If he's speaking Farsi, what does Abul-FaZl mean? There's no such thing. It's Abul Fadl. Can't you say "D"?
Your analogy was simply ridiculous. I am asking you to switch one letter - Z to D as a sign of respect for Abul Fadl Abbas. If this song were about Yazid or Rumi, I really wouldn't care if it was pronounced incorrectly.
ShiaAfghan (November 30, 1999 at 12:00 am)
"They spend entire lives on religious studies, something that im sure is not your profession. "
Sorry to depress you, but life isn't that nice. There are plenty of people who will go to Qom for 1 year, put a turban on their head, and say the craziest things possible.
"It isNT Haraam" When did I say it was haram? I'm simply asking you to pronounce it correctly.
gypsy5724 (November 30, 1999 at 12:00 am)
& dont forget that these arabic words r integrated in Farsi now. Farsi isNT the original Parsi language anymore, its a combination of Parsi & THE INFLUENCE of other languages - including the most prominant ARABIC. These Arabic words R now also FARSI WORDS & therefore when they R spoken in FARSI they R pronounced like FARSI WORDS & LETTERS. Alcohol is an English word derived from THE Arabic al-kuhl, but pronounced ALCOHOL in English and al-kuhl in Arabic. NATURAL! NOT HARAAM! Be fair, get over it |
